What advice do you give to a person in the following situation:
She is divorced from her ex husband and has embraced Islam for she has relied the truth and she was guided to the right path, Al Hamdulilah, her conversion is kept secret from her family for obvious reasons and her two children whom she has custody of are still Hindu because her ex husband would rather kill her than see his children embrace Islam. He is strong enemy of Islam and has sworn our deen and ALLAH on a few occasions. She is now in love with a religious and well mannered Muslim man who has asked her to marry him. The problem is that his parents object to their marriage because the mother feels that the lady in question is a convert and that converts don’t make good muslims. In fact her exact words were “They will never be one of us” If they do decide to make Nikaah can they for these reasons keep their marriage a secret. The man who has asked for her hand in marriage says that he will accept her children provided they embrace Islam because two religions cannot be practiced in one house especially when the other one is idol worship and I can’t agree with him more. How do these two people who love each other make a life of their own.
His parents are a problem on the one hand and the ex husband not wanting the children to embrace Islam is another problem.
My friend does not want to give up custody of her children because her ex husband is abusive. Please advise our sister as soon as possible as she is suffering from depression and sleepless nights.
May ALLAH bless our Prophet Muhammad.
Jazak Allah
Answer
Praise be to Allaah.
First of all, we would like to congratulate our sister for embracing Islam, which is the joy for which wealth and souls would be sacrificed, for all the blessing of Islam makes all grief and distress fade into insignificance.
The sister says that she loves a Muslim man. We say: it is not appropriate for a Muslim woman to fall into the trap of nonsensical emotions and forbidden relationships into which others fall. The love which people hear about and read about is one of the dazzling tricks of the Shaytaan, and it usually happens with regard to things that Allaah has forbidden. If a man finds that he likes a girl, the only option he has is to ask her guardian (walee) for permission to marry her.
The man’s mother’s comment that new Muslims cannot be good Muslims is false. Were the Sahaabah (may Allaah be pleased with them) anything but new Muslims, given that prior to their Islam they had been believers in Shirk? Does any Muslim have any doubts about their commitment to religion and their character? Moreover, we see that many new Muslims are many times better than many (born) Muslims! Just because a Muslim is new does not mean that he will never be good, and just because a Muslim is born in Islam does not mean that he is good. What counts is Taqwa (piety, awareness of Allaah) and righteous deeds, as well as the length of time one has been in Islam and has been worshipping Allaah.
There is no reason why knowledge of the man’s marriage should not be withheld from his parents, especially since this is in the interests of the sister and there are so few people who can help her to overcome her difficulties. It is the woman who needs a walee according to sharee’ah, not the man. However, we would prefer that he wins his family’s approval by convincing them, because this is in their best interests, benefits which may be lost if they find out that their son concealed his marriage from them.
The fact that the husband says he wants to call the children to Islam is good. We ask Allaah to help him to achieve this. The fact that the Hindu father is evil is sufficient reason for him not to make an open display of his calling the children to Islam, if that could lead to this kaafir taking the children away by going to the kaafir courts. You have to act with wisdom in this case.
The woman who is asking this question should not arrange her own marriage even if she has been previously married, because sharee’ah does not permit this. If she does not have a walee as required by sharee’ah, then her walee may be the qaadi (judge) or whoever is in charge of the Muslim affairs in her country, such as the head of the Islamic centre or his deputy.
They – especially the sister – have to seek the help of Allaah in dealing with these problems which are giving her sleepless nights. Everyone should know that whoever puts his trust in Allaah, Allaah will show him a way out. She has to make du’aa’ sincerely, and he has to try as hard as he can to advise his family and change their views about new Muslims by showing them real examples of people who are the opposite of what they think. With regard to the tragedy caused by the former husband, we advise her again not to make an open display of her calling the children to Islam, lest that should cause the father to do something that will have bad consequences. If they feel suspicious about his intentions, there is no harm in calling the police to do whatever is necessary with regard to him.
If getting married means that the sister will lose her right to custody of her children, we advise her not to get married now, for fear that these two souls may end up in Hell in the Hereafter – unless she fears that she herself may commit some immoral action, in which case she should marry the Muslim man whom she has told us about, with witnesses and a walee as we have stated above. Publicizing the marriage is sunnah, although it does not have to be announced officially and in writing. But this sister has to live in a protective Muslim environment and those people will have to know about her marriage lest she bring upon herself gossip about her honour. If it will be better for her to leave the place where her ex-husband lives and move to another place where she can be free, have custody of her children and be able to marry a believing Muslim man who will protect her and her children, then she should do that.
She has to make du’aa’ and turn to Allaah to relieve her distress and grief. We pray that Allaah will give her the strength to do that which He loves and which pleases Him.
And Allaah knows best.
Islam Q&A
Sheikh Muhammed Salih Al-Munajjid
Popularity: 18% [?]






Thanks for posting about this, I would love to read more about this topic.
fuck all the mother fucker musloms…
pedeophilic, child rapist demonic religion…
tat bitch converted to islam i will fight for the husband who wants to keep the children nd save them frm falling in this demonic pork eating religion…
fuck islam….mother fuckin cocksuckin allah
jai shri ram
hinduism rocks
Devil Sumeet. Don’t show us your real face of Hinduism, I don’t understand the religion where rats, snakes, cows, pennies and all other things are worshipped which is not a real thing to worship. I am shocked when I come to know who Ganesh was born. What is so called mother of Ganesh was taking a bath and from the collection of her body dirt she prepared a statue of a boy and then put the soul to protect her. My question since how many days she did not took the bath so that she has to collect so much dirt on her body and what a joke elephant’s head is fixed on a little boys body is that possible have anybody see the baby elephant’s head or not wake up Hindus.
I have a firend in similar situation. Alhumudliah her 2 children accpet islam too. But this girl fell into the traps of her family (her sister) and sent the children to India, where her ex-parents in law kept the children and made them strict sikhs.
Now the children are back to Hong Kong , but they are styaing with her own (non-muslim) parents. the children are strickly against her as now she has a new husbnad and a daughter.
But her parents are forcing her to sent the kids to the UK, to their uncle (a sikh). Now she doesn’t know what to do. As she can take the kids legaly but her kids doesn’t want to be with her.
You Idiot people from Islam. Who in the world likes terror religion? Spreading violence, killing people, converting people by cheating is not the real Islam. You people have come a long way from the true religion. Convert to Hinduism and try to save your family and children from sins. Your sins as a Muslim have surpassed the limit. Now there is only one way. Convert back to hinduism to go back to your true roots where your forefathers were following and live a better life. You are all converted muslims. Since Moghuls and other rulers attacked India, they converted all of your great grandfathers. In reality, you guys are also Hindus. In hindu religion, we respect every religion. But you guys have become rotten pigs. You eat, breath and live in a country and try to spread violence in your home country. First, learn to love your family, your neighbours and your country.
Fantastic article !
Have you considered adding video to your posts to keep the visitors entertained? I recently read through the entire article and it was good…tahnk you for the share
Well Mr. True Hindu, how much you as a Hindu “respect other religions” is vividly apparent from your comment. It is just an evidence of hypocrisy you seem to have as second nature. Also, do you by any chance read the newspaper to educate yourself of what is happening in the country? I guess you’re falling short there which is why you have made an ill-informed statement like “terror religion” and “you eat, breath and live in a country and try to spread violence in your home country”. What would you have to say about the Maoists blowing up the entire Eastern India? Who are they?… Muslim? Naaahhh…They are the so-called “peace loving” Hindus. And how about the September 29 bomb blast in the town of Malegaon? I hope you are not inflicted by amnesia to find it difficult to recall that one Lt Col Shrikant Purohit of the India army was arrested was this act. This was the same man who was also believed to be involved in the 2007 Samjhauta Express bombings. Have you heard of United Liberation Front of Assam (ULFA) and the Bodos? I have never heard them to be Muslim…in fact, all Hindus. And, lets refer to yet one more incident of 24th February 2008 when bomb blasts occurred in the RSS office & a Bus Stand in Tenkasi, Tamil Nadu…and you know who were arrested for this? Mr. Kannappan, DIG, Tirunelveli range arrested 3 persons - S Ravi Pandian who was a cable TV operator, S Kumar who was an auto driver and V Narayana Sharma (26) of Sencottai - all Sangh Parivar activists.
And I can go on and on about countless Hindu Terrorism events in India but, it would run beyond the scope of this website. So my dear, next time, when you open your trap (I mean your mouth) get your facts straight n right before you are beaten up hollow even in a war of words by just another Muslim girl… Imagine what Muslim men could be capable of.
And yes, India is NOT YOUR COUNTRY ALONE…NOT YOUR PERSONAL PROPERTY and you have no right WHATSOEVER to refer to Muslims living in India as “you live here, you eat here”…And, if you are so hell bent on anointing India as a Hindu nation, stop wagging your tongue and try to evacuate even a single Muslim from India…if you really have enough manhood and guts to take up this dare that I throw at you.
Lastly, notice the difference in our communication. You peace loving Hindu have not refrained from using abusive language and I being a Muslim, who you brand as terrorists and what not, have not used a single rude word in replying to you. Isn’t this a proof enough too about the true character of a Hindu?